[ChemRxiv] The origin of thymine in DNA remains a central puzzle in astrobiology. While Darwinian evolution may have refined RNA into DNA, the initial selection mechanism must have been purely chemical.
Here we present UPDSF v6.1.1—the Unified Prebiotic DNA Selection Framework—a mass-conserving, kinetically consistent stochastic model of hydrothermal-vent chemistry. At the optimum (90 °C, pH 11, dark vent), a chemical selection index (CSI) of 6.019× emerges through the multiplicative combination of real (direct) T-preferential hydrolysis and pool-composition drift.
The model reproduces all key experimental rates (Lindahl, 1993 ; Cleaves et al., 2010 ; Ferris, 1996 ; Sutherland et al., 2020) with explicit provenance tracking and two environmental channels only. UV damage is negligible (<2 % of CSI) under vent conditions. Sensitivity analysis shows that CSI is robust to freemonomer deamination scale and lipid protection, while the 356.96× (~357) fold extrapolated stability ratio (k_U/k_T) is bounded by the activation-energy sweep.
The framework is fully stochastic, provenance-tracked, and mass-consistent, providing a rigorous prebiotic pathway from Miller–Orgel monomers to thymine-rich DNA. We further compare our results with the complementary PNAS study of Khosh Abady, Karpourazar & Rentzepis (2026), which demonstrates that UV photodamage pathways act as the dominant evolutionary filter in surface environments.
Together, the two mechanisms form a complete two-stage prebiotic model: chemical filtering in the dark (UPDSF) followed by UV selection in the light (PNAS).
Astrobiology,
