- Status Report
- November 22, 2023
Life in the Galaxy: Is This as Good as It Gets?
Researchers have found that rocky exoplanets which formed early in the life of the galaxy seem to have had a greater chance of developing a magnetic field and plate tectonics than planets which formed later.
As both these conditions are considered favourable to the development of life, this means that if life exists in the galaxy, it may have developed earlier than later, and that planets formed more recently may have less chance of developing life.
As lead scientist, planetary researcher Craig O’Neill said, “Plate tectonics is important for habitability, and it looks like the optimum conditions plate tectonics existed for planets forming early in the galaxy’s lifespan, and may be unlikely to easily recur. For life, maybe that was as good as it gets.”
Exoplanets — planets in orbit around distant stars — have been attracting great interest because of the possibility that some of them may harbour life. Presenting the results at the Goldschmidt geochemistry conference, Professor Craig O’Neill (Director of the Macquarie Planetary Research Centre, Macquarie University) continued: “Because of the great distances involved, we have a limited amount of information on these exoplanets, but we can understand some factors, such as position, temperature, and some idea of the geochemistry of the exoplanets. This allows us to model how they develop.”
Using huge simulations involving hundreds of processors on the Australian National Computing Infrastructure, the team ran the parameters through the ASPECT* geodynamics code, which simulates the development of the interior of planets. O’Neill’s group was able to show that many early planets would have tended to develop plate tectonics, which is favourable to the development of life.
He commented: “Plate tectonics act as a kind of thermostat for the Earth creating the conditions which allow life to evolve. The Earth has a lot of iron in its core, and we had assumed that this would be necessary for tectonic development. However we found that even planets with little iron may develop plate tectonics if the timing is right. This was completely unexpected.”
The development of plate tectonics has a major knock-on effect. “Planets which formed later may not have developed plate tectonics, which means that they don’t have this built in thermostat. This doesn’t just affect the surface temperature, this means that the core stays hot, which inhibits the development of a magnetic field. If there’s no magnetic field, the planet is not shielded from solar radiation, and will tend to lose its atmosphere. So life becomes difficult to sustain. A planet needs to be lucky to have the right position and the right geochemistry at the right time if it’s going to sustain life,” said Professor O’Neill.
Researchers know that the overall chemical balance of the galaxy has changed over time for diverse reasons, such as material coalescing into stars and planetary bodies, or being expelled through supernova. This means that the interstellar material available to form planets is significantly different to that available in the early galaxy.
“So the planets which formed earlier did so in conditions favourable to allow the development of life” said Craig O’Neill, “These conditions are becoming increasingly rarer in our galaxy.”
Commenting, Professor Sara Russell said: “Over the last few years, amazing projects such as the NASA Kepler mission have located thousands of planets orbiting around other stars. However, these exoplanet observations alone provide very basic information. It is so important to combine observing campaigns with large simulation projects like this, that really tell us something about the geological evolution of planets formed at different stages of galactic evolution. This enables us to build a picture of what these strange worlds might look like, and how habitable they may be.”
Sara Russell is a member of the Scientific Committee of the Geochemical Society. She is Professor of Planetary Sciences and leader of the Planetary Materials Group at the Natural History Museum, London. She was not involved in this work; this is an independent comment.
*Advanced Solver for Problems in Earth’s ConvecTion (https://aspect.geodynamics.org). ASPECT was developed by the University of California (Davis) with funding from the National Science Foundation.
Reference (Goldschmidt conference abstract):
“How Does Galactic Chemical Evolution Affect Terrestrial Planet Composition and Tectonics?” Craig O’Neill (Macquarie Planetary Research Centre, Macquarie University, Sydney, Australia) — The exoplanet catalogue of terrestrial planets has grown enormously in the past decade, but our ability to characterise these bodies had not. A key unknown is the compositional variation in Earth-scale planets, and how factors such as the evolution of galactic reservoirs may have systematically impacted the composition of planets. Galactic chemical evolution models (GCEs) have been used to calculate the evolution of the interstellar media over time, and have suggested systematic trends in the availability of geophysically critical elements, such as Fe (relative to Si), and heat producing elements (HPEs) U, Th And K, suggesting a systematic diluting of heat producing elements over time, and an increase in Fe/Si due to increased Type Ia supernova activity since galaxy formation. Here we test the consequences of these trends for terrestrial planet behaviour, assuming solar:Earth element partitioning for terrestrial Earth-sized exoplanets. The concentration of the geophysically critical elements determine core size, gravity, and internal temperatures, and govern the geodynamics of these systems. We have varied the Fe/Si ratios/core size of simulated planets, and use a mineral physics package to calculate internal structures, physical properties, and gravity. We then use the mantle convection code Aspect to simulate their evolution. Planets forming early in the Milky Way’s history tend to have low Fe/Si ratios, and thus small cores, although elevated HPE budgets. The convection configuration and lower temperature in planets that have large mantle fractions relative to the Earth tends to promote high stress in the lithosphere and cause tectonic activity. Together with weaker surface faults due to lower gravity, such small-core planets show enhanced plate tectonic behaviour. In contrast, currently forming planets have large Fe/Si, core size, higher gravity, and a lower propensity to plate tectonics. Our results suggest a strong tendency towards plate tectonics on Earth-sized planets early in galactic history, with the tendency for tectonics diminishing as the galaxy has evolved.
Please mention the Goldschmidt Conference in any article resulting from this press release.